| Platinum | Gringo's Mexican Kitchen Restaurant |
| Gold | Iguanas Ranas Cantina |
| Silver | Lila's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Barcena's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Celaya Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Emma's Mex Grill |
| Top Pick | Juanita's Taqueria |
| Top Pick | LA Casita Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Luna's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Lupe Tortillas |